• 1960 Phim trắng đen Alexander Trauner, Edward G. Boyle - The Apartment
  • Joseph McMillan Johnson, Kenneth A. Reid, Ross Dowd - The Facts of Life
  • Joseph Hurley, Robert Clatworthy, George Milo - Psycho
  • Tom Morahan, Lionel Couch - Sons and Lovers
  • Hal Pereira, Walter Tyler, Samuel M. Comer, Arthur Krams - Visit to a Small Planet
• 1960 Phim màu Alexander Golitzen, Eric Orbom (posthumous award), Russell A. Gausman, Julia Heron - Spartacus
  • George Davis, Addison Hehr, Henry Grace, Hugh Hunt, Otto Siegel - Cimarron
  • Hal Pereira, Roland Anderson, Samuel M. Comer, Arrigo Breschi - It Started in Naples
  • Ted Haworth, William Kiernan - Pepe
  • Edward Carrere, George James Hopkins - Sunrise at Campobello
• 1961 Phim trắng đen Harry Horner, Gene Callahan - The Hustler
  • Carroll Clark, Emile Kuri, Hal Gausman - The Absent-Minded Professor
  • Fernando Carrere, Edward G. Boyle - The Children's Hour
  • Rudolf Sternad, George Milo - Judgment at Nuremberg
  • Piero Gherardi - La dolce vita
• 1961 Phim màu Boris Leven, Victor A. Gangelin - West Side Story
  • Hal Pereira, Roland Anderson, Samuel M. Comer, Ray Moyer - Breakfast at Tiffany's
  • Veniero Colasanti, John Moore - El Cid
  • Alexander Golitzen, Joseph Wright, Howard Bristol - Flower Drum Song
  • Hal Pereira, Walter Tyler, Samuel M. Comer, Arthur Krams - Summer and Smoke
• 1962 Phim trắng đen Alexander Golitzen, Henry Bumstead, Oliver Emert - To Kill a Mockingbird
  • Joseph Wright, George James Hopkins - Days of Wine and Roses
  • Ted Haworth, Léon Barsacq, Vincent Korda, Gabriel Bechir - The Longest Day
  • George Davis, Edward Carfagno, Henry Grace, Dick Pefferle - Period of Adjustment
  • Hal Pereira, Roland Anderson, Samuel M. Comer, Frank R. McKelvy - The Pigeon That Took Rome
• 1962 Phim màu John Box, John Stoll, Dario Simoni - Lawrence of Arabia
  • Paul Groesse, George James Hopkins - The Music Man
  • George Davis, J. McMillan Johnson, Henry Grace, Hugh Hunt - Mutiny on the Bounty
  • Alexander Golitzen, Robert Clatworthy, George Milo - That Touch of Mink
  • George Davis, Edward Carfagno, Henry Grace, Dick Pefferle - The Wonderful World of the Brothers Grimm
• 1963 Phim trắng đen Gene Callahan - America America
  • Piero Gherardi - 8½
  • Hal Pereira, Tambi Larsen, Samuel M. Comer, Robert R. Benton - Hud
  • Hal Pereira, Roland Anderson, Samuel M. Comer, Grace Gregory - Love with the Proper Stranger
  • George Davis, Paul Groesse, Henry Grace, Hugh Hunt - Twilight of Honor
• 1963 Phim màu John DeCuir, Jack Martin Smith, Hilyard Brown, Herman Blumenthal, Elven Webb, Maurice Pelling, Boris Juraga, Walter M. Scott, Paul S. Fox, Ray Moyer - Cleopatra
  • Lyle Wheeler, Gene Callahan - The Cardinal
  • Hal Pereira, Roland Anderson, Samuel M. Comer, James W. Payne - Come Blow Your Horn
  • George Davis, William Ferrari (posthumous nomination), Addison Hehr, Henry Grace, Don Greenwood Jr., Jack Mills - How the West Was Won
  • Ralph Brinton, Ted Marshall, Jocelyn Herbert, Josie MacAvin - Tom Jones
• 1964 Phim trắng đen Vassilis Fotopoulos - Zorba the Greek (Alexis Zorbas)
  • George Davis, Hans Peters, Elliot Scott, Henry Grace, Robert R. Benton - The Americanization of Emily
  • William Glasgow, Raphael Bretton - Hush… Hush, Sweet Charlotte
  • Stephen Grimes - The Night of the Iguana
  • Cary Odell, Edward G. Boyle - Seven Days in May
• 1964 Phim màu Gene Allen, Cecil Beaton, George James Hopkins - My Fair Lady
  • John Bryan, Maurice Carter, Patrick McLoughlin, Robert Cartwright - Becket
  • Carroll Clark, William H. Tuntke, Emile Kuri, Hal Gausman - Mary Poppins
  • George Davis, E. Preston Ames, Henry Grace, Hugh Hunt - The Unsinkable Molly Brown
  • Jack Martin Smith, Ted Haworth, Walter M. Scott, Stuart A. Reiss - What a Way to Go!
• 1965 Phim trắng đen Robert Clatworthy, Joseph Kish - Ship of Fools
  • Robert Emmet Smith, Frank Tuttle - King Rat
  • George Davis, Urie McCleary, Henry Grace, Charles S. Thompson - A Patch of Blue
  • Hal Pereira, Jack Poplin, Robert R. Benton, Joseph Kish - The Slender Thread
  • Hal Pereira, Tambi Larsen, Ted Marshall, Josie MacAvin - The Spy Who Came in from the Cold
• 1965 Phim màu John Box, Terence Marsh, Dario Simoni - Doctor Zhivago
  • John DeCuir, Jack Martin Smith, Dario Simoni - The Agony and the Ecstasy
  • Richard Day, William Creber, David S. Hall (posthumous nomination), Ray Moyer, Fred M. MacLean, Norman Rockett - The Greatest Story Ever Told
  • Robert Clatworthy, George James Hopkins - Inside Daisy Clover
  • Boris Leven, Walter M. Scott, Ruby Levitt - The Sound of Music
• 1966 Phim trắng đen Richard Sylbert, George James Hopkins - Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf?
  • Robert Luthardt, Edward G. Boyle - The Fortune Cookie
  • Luigi Scaccianoce - Tin Mừng theo thánh Mátthêu (Il Vangelo secondo Matteo)
  • Willy Holt, Marc Frederix, Pierre Guffroy - Is Paris Burning?
  • George Davis, Paul Groesse, Henry Grace, Hugh Hunt - Mister Buddwing
• 1966 Phim màu Jack Martin Smith, Dale Hennesy, Walter M. Scott, Stuart A. Reiss - Fantastic Voyage
  • Alexander Golitzen, George C. Webb, John McCarthy, Jr., John Austin - Gambit
  • Piero Gherardi - Juliet of the Spirits (Giulietta degli spiriti)
  • Hal Pereira, Arthur Lonergan, Robert R. Benton, James W. Payne - The Oscar
  • Boris Leven, Walter M. Scott, John Sturtevant, William Kiernan - The Sand Pebbles

Từ năm 1967 hai loại giải lại nhập thành một.

• 1967 John Truscott, Edward Carrere, John W. Brown - Camelot
  • Mario Chiari, Jack Martin Smith, Ed Graves, Walter M. Scott, Stuart A. Reiss - Doctor Dolittle
  • Robert Clatworthy, Frank Tuttle - Guess Who's Coming to Dinner
  • Renzo Mongiardino, John DeCuir, Elven Webb, Giuseppe Mariani, Dario Simoni, Luigi Gervasi - The Taming of the Shrew
  • Alexander Golitzen, George C. Webb, Howard Bristol - Thoroughly Modern Millie
• 1968 John Box, Terence Marsh, Vernon Dixon, Ken Muggleston - Oliver!
  • George Davis, Edward Carfagno - The Shoes of the Fisherman
  • Boris Leven, Walter M. Scott, Howard Bristol - Star!
  • Anthony Masters, Harry Lange, Ernie Archer - 2001: A Space Odyssey
  • Mikhail Bogdanov, Gennady Myasnikov, Georgi Koshelev, Vladimir Uvarov - War and Peace (Война и мир)
• 1969 John Decuir, Jack Martin Smith, Herman Blumenthal, Walter M. Scott, George Hopkins, Raphael Bretton - Hello, Dolly!
  • Maurice Carter, Lionel Couch, Patrick McLoughlin - Anne of the Thousand Days
  • Robert F. Boyle, George B. Chan, Edward G. Boyle, Carl Biddiscombe - Gaily, Gaily
  • Alexander Golitzen, George C. Webb, Jack D. Moore - Sweet Charity
  • Harry Horner, Frank McKelvy - They Shoot Horses, Don't They?